Why Not Video Documentation?
Date Posted: January 28, 2010 12:00 AM

Programmers are notorious for their dislike of documenting code. (I'm no exception! Comments in code aren't too bad, but writing documentation for users?!) Nonetheless, we all have to do it, right? I know that in our shop, we need to create "run books" that explain step-by-step how a user is to perform a particular task, such as entering an order or adding a customer.

Written documentation works OK for plain-text screens. But it never works as well as demonstrating the process for the user, where he can see the screens as I'm typing the commands. With GUI software, being able to see the actual screens is even more important. For example, written software that has instructions like "click the doo-hickey that looks like a curly arrow" can be hard to follow.

Therefore, I'm proclaiming that the age of video documentation has officially begun! With video documentation, you can easily create a step-by-step tutorial for your users and show them exactly what the screens look like, and they can watch it anytime. Best of all, it's free!

Wink, Wink, Nudge, Nudge

There are many software packages that you can use to create video documentation. I've settled on a program named Wink by Satish Kumar. Wink is freeware, which means you can download it from the author and use it free of charge. It's available for both Windows and Linux. You can get your copy at the following link:
debugmode.com/wink/

Of course, one disadvantage of freeware is that no support is offered. If you want support, you can go with a commercial product. There's also a commercial alternative named Jing that has been highly recommended by Jon Paris in some of his talks. Jing is available in a free version (served from Jing's servers, with limited features) or a Pro version that requires a subscription. Here's a link to the Jing website:
jingproject.com/

Since I'm too cheap to pay for Jing, and since I want to host documentation from my own website (not to mention System iNetwork's site), I've been using Wink.

What Wink Does

You start Wink and tell it to capture the contents of your PC desktop or the contents of a specific Window on your PC. Then you do your work as normal, and it records your screen, making a recording of what you do. When you tell it that you're done, it brings up an editor where you can edit what you've just done (if necessary) and then render the result as a movie.

The movie is recorded in Adobe's Shockwave Flash (swf) format. That's the same format used by online services such as YouTube and Facebook. Just about every web browser on the planet has Flash installed, so you can put your video on a web page and ask your users to point their browser to the video. The Apache HTTP server available on IBM i will work nicely for this, as will Apache running on another platform, or even Microsoft's IIS. If running a web server isn't practical, you could even put these files on a CD-ROM so that when the CD is inserted, it'll automatically play in the user's browser.

If hosting your own web server is a problem in your shop, try using Jing instead. With Jing, the video is hosted on Jing's site instead of your own.

A Traditional Example

Recently, I used Wink to create some instructions to post in a thread in the System iNetwork forums. There was a question from someone who was new to our platform. The poster was interested in how he could get a list of users on the system and then select an option that would delete a given user and change all objects to be owned by someone else.

The immediate response in the forums was "use the WRKUSRPRF command." But the original poster wasn't familiar enough with the system to understand how WRKUSRPRF solved his problem, and he couldn't visualize the screens.

So I fired up Wink, ran through the process in my 5250 emulator, and created the following video:

If you have trouble viewing the preceding video, click here to view it in its original format.

A few notes about the preceding example:

  • If the tutorial goes too fast, the user can always click the "pause" button in the lower-left corner of the video.
  • I first recorded the process using Wink.
  • Since I didn't have a microphone handy, I couldn't narrate it. So I used Wink's editor to insert those yellow boxes with explanatory text.
  • Wink does support audio narration, however.
  • As this is a green-screen example, it wouldn't have been difficult to document it on paper with screen shots, but this way was easier for me!

A GUI Example with Audio

I thought the preceding example was pretty neat, and it was easy to make. It took me less than 30 minutes to make, and most of that time was spent trying to figure out how to insert the text boxes.

Because it was a green-screen example, however, I wondered if people reading this article would say, "Why bother? I could do that easily with screen shots and instructions." So I wanted to demonstrate a GUI example that did use sound.

This example is to demonstrate how to upload a picture for an employee into Klement's Sausage Company's employee attendance software. (This is a program that I wrote to keep track of employee attendance, and our HR department wanted to be able to store a picture of employees alongside their attendance record.) Having sound made this process much easier, since I didn't have to try to insert comments into it—I could just record my voice as I did the work. The following took me less than 10 minutes to create:

If you have trouble viewing the preceding video, click here to view it in its original format.


Granted, this is a very short procedure, but 10 minutes to create documentation that's this easy for the users to follow? It's hard to beat!

Concluding Thoughts

If you work for a consultancy or a software house, you will almost certainly still need to have paper documentation. In that case, having video documentation like this won't save you any time but may still enhance the experience for your clients. They'll enjoy having this as an alternative (and often better) way of learning about your product.

If you're an in-house programmer like me, you might be able to eliminate some of the paper documentation altogether. Video documentation is often easier for the user and is a time-saver for the programmer creating it.

What do you think of this idea? Would you like to see a tutorial explaining how I created these videos? Or an example of how you'd put them on a CD-ROM? Do you think this method of documentation has merit? Post your thoughts as a comment, below!


Want to use this article? Click here for options!
Want to subscribe? Click here!
  • tips@scottklement.com
    2 years ago
    Feb 16, 2010

    Sorry to all of the people who are having trouble viewing the videos.



    I had to change the code generated by Wink in order to put it into the System iNetwork article database. Those changes seem to have broken something in Internet Explorer. If you view the article in Firefox or Chrome, you'll see that it works nicely. however, Internet Explorer seems to go absolutely crazy. I can't figure out why.



    If you'd like to see the videos in their original format (before I modified them) you can find the two example videos here:




    These should work properly in IE -- and they also work properly in FF and Chrome.

  • EdwardJ
    2 years ago
    Feb 10, 2010

    I am an in-house programmer like yourself and I would also like to be able to create a video documentation for user training as you have described. I was therefore quite excited on reading your article. However, I am unable to look at your example video in wink. What do I have to do to be able to see it?

    Having said that I still think it is a gresat idea. I would most certainly welcome a tutorial explaining how I created such videos.
    as well as an example of how you'd putting them on a CD-ROM.

    This method of documentation most certainly have lots of merit. I've recently been looking at the Valence at the CNXCORP site.
    Their videos have really impressed me and naturally I'd like to try doing somthing similar on a smaller scale.

    So I'm looking forward to the followup articles.

    EJ.




  • tips@scottklement.com
    2 years ago
    Feb 02, 2010

    Jon: Thanks for the input..



    TerryB: In my experience, the visuals from Wink are identical to what you see on the screen. I have to muck about to get the timing right sometimes, but never had a problem with the visuals looking different from the screen itself. Can you expand upon the problem you have with visuals?

  • terryb@anvilknitwear.com
    2 years ago
    Feb 01, 2010

    I would like to see you create a tutorial as I have been looking for a tool for creating user instructions as you have described. I have reviewed the wink product but am having problems with the end results being of very poor visual quality. I have tried changing the screen resolution during the capture process apparently have not hit on the right settings.

  • jon.paris@partner400.com
    2 years ago
    Jan 28, 2010

    Just to clarify a couple of points regarding Jing Scott.


    1. The free version does not require that you host videos with Screencast - you can save them locally and serve them from anywhere you want. Personally I use Screencast becuase all of mine are served to the outside universe and I'd rather not use up my internet bandwidth, but it is not compulsory.


    2. Jing Pro does have a charge associted with it - but at only $15 per year I find the fact that I get a fully supported version plus additional features well worth the money.


    3. Jing also works with the Mac - which as a Mac user is important to me.




    Jon Paris

  • You must log on before posting a comment.

    Are you a new visitor? Register Here
     

    around the forums

    better data access for AS400 applications
    Forum Name: Systems Management
    21 May 2012 06:22 AM | Replies: 0
    Selection error involving field *N.
    Forum Name: SQL, Query and Database
    18 May 2012 02:19 PM | Replies: 6
    WINDOWS 7 with CLIENT ACCESS 7 R1
    Forum Name: Communications/Networking
    18 May 2012 08:43 AM | Replies: 1

    ProVIP Sponsors

    BCD

    Join Our Community!

    Subscribe today to iPro Developer! iPro Developer is packed with technical know-how for developers of IBM i, iSeries, AS400 and System i. Sign up now to get your full subscriber benefits including:

    • Code available for download
    • Full access to the online article archive (including all System iNEWS ProVIP content)
    • Downloadable ebook with past 6 months of articles
    • Discounts on eLearning classes, self-paced training, in-person events, and more!
    iPro Developer Newsletters
    • Get the Latest News
    • Product Updates
    • Helpful Tricks
    • Productivity Tips